Fresh PCB Concepts: PPAP Is Not Just for Automotive
The production part approval process (PPAP) is usually associated with the automotive industry, where it was developed and remains most widely required. However, the value of PPAP is not limited to vehicles. The same principles apply wherever consistent performance is critical, particularly in medical and other high reliability applications. In my column this month, I’ll cover why a proven automotive tool applies to medical and other consistency critical applications.
At its core, PPAP is a structured method of demonstrating that a supplier understands the product requirements and has a robust, controlled process for repeatedly producing a conforming product. It connects the product requirements to the manufacturing process and creates the evidence needed for formal customer approval.
That distinction is important. PPAP is not simply a collection of quality documents, and it should not be treated as a paperwork exercise. A properly developed PPAP package provides objective evidence that the product and the process have been reviewed together before full production begins.
A first article report is important, but it is not a PPAP. A first article report confirms that the measured characteristics of an initial production sample meet the specified requirements. This is valuable information, but it represents a snapshot of the product at a particular point in time.
PPAP goes further. It documents how the manufacturing process is intended to produce and control those characteristics on an ongoing basis. A supplier may be capable of producing one acceptable part while still lacking the controls needed to produce the same result consistently across multiple production lots.
For PCBs, that difference can be significant. PCB fabrication depends on a long sequence of interdependent processes. Variation introduced at any stage can affect the finished product, even when the drawing and Gerber data have not changed.
A first article tells us whether the initial board met the requirements. PPAP helps establish whether the complete manufacturing process is prepared to continue meeting them.
Why PPAP Makes Sense for Medical Products
Medical electronics often operate in applications where strict process control is essential. Traceability and change control are equally important because an unexpected PCB failure can affect equipment performance and, in some cases, create serious consequences for the end user.
The PCB is a custom-manufactured product and should always be built to print. The fabricator does not own the design, but it makes many process decisions that directly influence the finished result. These decisions are not always visible in the customer supplied design files.
PPAP creates a formal connection between design intent and the factory's processes used to achieve it. It establishes an approved product and process baseline supported by objective evidence and controlled through customer authorization.
This is particularly useful when a product moves from prototype to production. Prototype and production factories may not use the same manufacturing methods or controls. A successful prototype does not automatically demonstrate that the production process is ready. PPAP provides a structured way to qualify that process before the prototype becomes the de facto production standard.
What Is Included in a PPAP?
The exact content should reflect the customer requirements and the level of risk associated with the product. Depending on the agreed scope, a PPAP may include:
- Design records and applicable product specifications
- Documentation of authorized engineering changes
- A manufacturing process flow diagram
- Process Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (PFMEA)
- A control plan linking identified risks to production controls
- Measurement system analysis
- Dimensional, material, and performance test results
- Initial process capability data for applicable characteristics
- Qualified laboratory documentation
- Sample production parts and retained master samples
- The Part Submission Warrant (PSW)
- Customer-specific material and regulatory declarations, including an accepted IMDS submission when required
Not every PCB program needs the same submission package. A lower-risk industrial control and a life-supporting medical device should not automatically be treated the same way. The objective is to apply the appropriate level of control and evidence based on the consequences of variation or failure.
PPAP includes five submission levels. The level determines which records are submitted to the customer or reviewed at the manufacturing site. It does not necessarily change the supplier’s responsibility to complete and retain all applicable PPAP records. The appropriate level should be defined by the customer based on product risk and approval needs. PPAP remains the industry-standard method for demonstrating that design and specification requirements can be consistently met under production conditions.
AIAG Production Part Approval Process
Level 1: The supplier submits the PSW. An appearance approval report may also be required when appearance is a designated product requirement.
Level 2: The supplier submits the PSW, production samples, and a limited selection of supporting records defined by the customer.
Level 3: The supplier submits the PSW, production samples, and the complete supporting PPAP package for customer review.
Level 4: The supplier submits the PSW and any additional information specifically defined by the customer. This allows the submission to be tailored to the product or program.
Level 5: The supplier completes the full PPAP package, which is reviewed at the supplier’s manufacturing location. Production samples and other records are made available as required.
Level 3 is the most commonly requested submission level because it gives the customer a complete package of objective evidence without requiring an onsite review for every approval. It provides a practical way to confirm that the product requirements are understood and that the manufacturing process can consistently produce conforming PCBs.
The submission level alone does not define an effective PPAP. The customer and supplier must agree on the scope and approval requirements before work begins. A tailored package may be more appropriate than requesting every possible element without considering its relevance to the product.
If PPAP is required, it should be clearly identified in the procurement data. The submission level and applicable requirements should be defined during sourcing and quotation, not after the product has already been built. Developing and maintaining a PPAP package requires engineering and quality resources. It may also require additional validation or another controlled production run. This can add cost and lead time that must be considered during quotation.
For automotive products, PPAP requirements may also include submission of the product’s material composition through the International Material Data System (IMDS), which is used throughout the automotive supply chain to document the materials and substances contained within a finished product. Although it is not required for every PPAP, many automotive customers make an accepted IMDS submission a condition of product approval. This requirement should be defined before quotation because collecting and validating the necessary material data may require coordination throughout the supply chain.
A late PPAP request can be much more disruptive. If the required data were not collected during the original production run, the supplier may need to repeat testing or produce another lot under controlled conditions. Clear expectations at the beginning allow the supplier to build the necessary evidence into the production plan.
The procurement data should clearly define the required submission package and the conditions that trigger resubmission. This removes ambiguity and ensures the supplier understands the approval expectations before production begins.
PPAP does not eliminate manufacturing risk, and a completed package does not guarantee that a failure can never occur. What it does is provide a disciplined way to evaluate process risk and approve a controlled production baseline based on objective evidence. This is why PPAP is useful well beyond automotive. The process addresses a universal manufacturing question: Can the supplier repeatedly produce the same conforming product using a stable and controlled process?
For medical products and other demanding applications, one successful build is not enough. Long-term reliability depends on a controlled manufacturing system supported by strong traceability and disciplined change management. PPAP brings these requirements together in a format that both the customer and supplier can review and approve.
PPAP may have started in automotive, but its purpose is much broader. Wherever consistency is critical to the end use application, PPAP can provide the structure and evidence needed to build confidence in both the product and the process behind it.
Jeffrey Beauchamp is a field applications engineer with NCAB Group.